Apple Watch | Immediate Competitors | |
Product | There are 4 versions (Apple watch series 4; Apple watch series 3; Apple watch Nike + and Apple watch Hermes) of smartwatches, predominately under two series, GPS and GPS + Cellular Highly customizable smart watches, which allows the customers to select their own Apple Watch face sizes, band styles (i.e. Casetify printed band, Nike sport band, Hoco original stainless steel band and etc) and colors. Present total integration of product with Apple hardware (iPhone, iPad) and software (IOS, iTunes, Apple store). This enable people to stay connected through calls and text even when they don’t have their phones with them. Make payments through Apple watch using credit or debit card Apple smart watch is well known for its high quality and innovations Up to 14 calendar days to return the product from the time customer receive it, at no cost or they can simply drop it off at any Apple store. |
Health track specifically designed for female—Fitbit Better Battery Life (i.e up to 30 days with regular use and up to 45 days with minimal notifications)— Xiaomi Customizable watch face designs and features (i.e. personal weatherman) (Chen 2019)—Xiaomi Amazfit Bip Water, dust, temperature and scratch resistance ow ing to the Gorila 3 SR+ glass (Samsung n.d.)— Samsung Allows voice assistance and measures over 21 in door and 39 outdoor fitness activities (Carnoy 2018) —Samsung Personnel fitness coaching app—Fitbit Value given for consumer feedback when designing products—Fitbit (Personal Goal Setting App) was developed in response to the customer feedback on requiring for a more personalized digital guidance for fitness activities. |
Price | Apple pursue premium pricing strategy: its’ prices range CNY 2,142 (Series 3) to CNY 11,396 (Series 4) Company sell products at a higher margin compared to other competitors stressing on the product value cater through differentiation and brand recognition. Apple facilitates customers to get up to CNY960 in credit of Apple store gift card towards new device if cus tomer traded their smartwatches (eligible Apple Watch Series 3 (GPS + Cellular) with stainless steel case) |
Premium quality for less price, brands such as Sam sung (i.e. GearS3 – CNY1,649) or Fitbit (i.e. Fitbit Versa – CNY1,298) have a lower relative base price compared to Apple Watch (i.e. Series 3 GPS – CNY2,142) Priced for the value addition (i.e. Xiaomi Amazfit – CNY799) opposite to Apple Watch’s premium pric ing strategy Less cost more sales pricing strategy—Xiaomi Offering a separate line of smartwatches with basic functions for cost conscious customers—Fitbit |
Place | Strong retail network: 42 Apple retail stores in China (Apple Inc. n.d.) Direct sales channel: Apple stores placed on major cities (Shanghai, Beijing, and Hangzhou) and shopping malls (Eg: China central mall, West Lake shopping Centre in Hangzhou) Apple online stores Apple pursue free next business day delivery to most of the metro areas for its watches |
Strategic usage of channel marketing —Samsung (strong in distribution network) Usage of Omni-channel strategy—Samsung aims to connect physical and digital retail and connect every point of shopping experience of the customer (Howse 2017) Efficient usage of traditional channels—Fitbit (available in store) |
Promotion | Advertising (Media presence, magazines, and bill boards): Vogue China decorated its cover page with the Chinese super model Liu Wen wearing an Apple watch which indicates that apple trying to build brand associa tion with the community Mobile advertisements: on tram station and bus stops. Apple launched a large promotional campaign to attract Chinese customers by encouraging them to use Apple Pay for shopping |
Effective usage of social media and e–commerce for marketing—Xiaomi (it barely use TV ads or physical banner ads but rather focusing on the benefit of using social media, internet and word-of-mouth to promote its watches) (Karam 2018) Effective usage of third party sales, through the use of agencies and intermediate parties —Huawei |
Strengths: Attractive design, customization and replaceable band of Apple Watch differentiate the product from competitors Apple has unique identity and global status, which can increase the brand loyalty and enhance the brand image. Since the supply chain is based in China, which allows Apple to obtain the full control of the manufacturing process A cellular connection or eSIM technology is the latest feature of Apple Watch series 4, which allows consumers to use the Watch independently without their iPhone (Kahn 2018) Weaknesses: Apple Watch only supports the IOS system, whereas other smartwatches have the option to pair with other operating systems. Low battery capacity of Apple Watch has led other competi tors to take it as an opportunity to gain the competitive ad vantage Market cannibalism: Apple Watch may decline the sales of iPhone as it replaces the function of the smartphone The unique design of the Apple Watch has increased the replicates (Saltzman 2019) Opportunities: The growth of children’s smartwatches in China allows Apple Watch to expand its product line The continuous growth of Chinese economy and technological development (Gilbert 2013) has increased the affordability of people in demanding smartwatches The busy lifestyles and health consciousness have boosted up the need in wearable devices that can assist people to get up dates on their health and business schedules. Threats: The growth of local brand (i.e. Xiaomi and Huawei) has in creased the competition as people tend to choose local brand over international brands in order to support the domestic economy Even Apple Watch is assembled in China, as an international brand, it still subject to the high tariff rate, which continuous to make its product more expensive. Due to the lower price offered by Xiaomi, its shipment has excelled Apple (IDC Worldwide Quarterly Wearables Trackers, 2018) |
SWOT Analysis |
Porter’s Five Forces | |
Threat of New Entrants Apple Watch ranks #1 in the Chinese smartwatch industry due to its successful brand reputation, whereas, itself does not elimi nate the threat of new entrants, especially corporations are will ing to take risks and challenge the status quo with differentiated products without fearing to damage their brand associations. The R&D of smartwatches requires companies to have a sub stantial amount of upfront cost (roughly $40 million) in order to rapidly build the foundation (Sacconaghi, Garfunkel & Colledge 2005, p. 47) in the industry. Therefore, a higher capital require ment may set up effective barriers to new entrants. The International Data Corporation (IDC) shows that in 2018 (3rd quarter), China’s smartwatch shipments reached 14.5 mil lion with a growth rate of 13% year-on-year (Draper 2019). This adoption rate may create incentives for companies to par ticipate in the market. |
Threat of Substitution The threat of substitute product for Apple Watch is high, since Apple Watch requires to pair with a specific operating system (IOS), unlike other smartwatches (i.e. Wear OS) that are capable of operating with both IOS and Android systems/ phones, which might be a more flexible option for users. Whereas, brand loyalty may limit the threat of substitution, as Apple buyers sometimes have the propensity not to switch to other brands/products. Given Apple Watch has emphasised its abilities of a fitness and sleep tracker, it also dives directly into competition with current fitness wearables (i.e. Fitbit) (Jary 2019). |
Bargaining power of suppliers Given Apple has hundreds of suppliers (Apple Inc. n.d.) in pro ducing various components of the Apple Watch, the bargaining power of suppliers is relatively weak in the marketplace, as Ap ple has the flexibility to choose from among a huge number of potential suppliers to produce components for its Apple Watch. Since the competition in making Apple’s components is rela tively high, the switching cost for Apple to change from one supplier to another is not a significant obstacle for the company. Where in fact, Apple demands its suppliers meet higher stand ards and as well as higher restrictions and benchmarks for build ing safe and respectful workplaces. |
Bargaining power of buyers Buyers tend to have a stronger bargaining power when they buy large volumes in relation to the sales, or when the prod uct is standardised/undifferentiated in the industry (Wolff 2016, p. 698). For Apple Watch, individual bargaining pow er is relatively weak, as the loss of one buyer may represent a negligible amount of sales for the whole company. The collective marketplace bargaining power of buyers can sometimes be seen as a strong force, especially when a mas sive number of buyers are defecting to Apple Watch’s com petitors. |
Intensity of Industry Rivalry The competitive force within the wearable electronics industry is strong, given not just Apple itself, but its competitors (i.e. Xiao mi, Samsung or Sony) all have invested significant capital on research and development for smartwatches. The rivalry among the competitors of Apple Watch will not only limit to wearable electronics industry giants, but also the ‘contactless’ payment system or health tracking features, as well as other smart clothing and accessories (i.e. smart glasses) that would meet the same need |
Political factor The trend of nationalising decision made by the Chinese gov ernment may discourage private ownership of technological companies (i.e. Apple Inc.) (Blading 2018) The Chinese government pressures multinational businesses to produce and source domestically, which could adversely impact companies if they could not find necessary material with the expected quality in China. The trade war between the US and China can heavily increase tariffs and trade barriers (Salinas 2018), which discourage the Chinese people to buy international products (i.e. Apple Watch) |
Economical factor Due to high tariffs imposed by the US, consumers will have to bear the burden of tax and pay more for Apple Watch. Being the second largest economy in the world, Chine has a favourable GDP growth rate. Whereas, the large amount of foreign currency reserve of USD 3 trillion (Santander 2019) can be considered as a healthy indicator to serve any unex pected downturns in economy, which creates a more stable and safe business environment. |
Social factor In 2018, 11.9% growth of elder population was recorded and in next 30 years, people aged 65 and over expected to make up 30% of china population (Agencia EFE 2019), which arise the need of expanding the market strategy from focusing on youth to older generation. Sourcing from: The world bank, population ages 65 and above, 2017 The hierarchical culture and power distance in China and the casual culture in the US may arise cultural conflicts between the operations of two countries. International companies (i.e. Apple) who want to operate in China, should be familiar with the local culture, which is shaped with Confucianism (Lunicheva 2014) and other unique cultural aspects. People in China are obsessed with using luxury items, and since Apple has been classified under the expensive brand cate gory, therefore, it may provide more opportunities for the com pany to expand. |
Environmental factors In 2007, China became the world’s biggest emitter of carbon dioxide and other gases (Zhang and Da 2015). In order to overcome this situation (the growing concerns in global warm ing), the China government has imposed strict regulations to protect the environment, which makes the companies to adhere to these rules, while operating in China. With the growing concern in water scarcity, companies are advised to implement water and waste management systems (Jiang 2009), which can be a costly decision for the firm to address. China has signed the Basel Convention Agreement to limit the toxic waste (Duan et al. 2008), this leads companies to focus more on the sustainable operations, and practice sound envi ronmental protection programs. |
Technological factor Since people recognise the benefit of using technology as a crucial part of their daily lifestyle, it may increase the demand for high-tech wearables such as Apple Watch. With the growth of technological aspect in China (i.e. Artificial Intelligence and 5G networks) with other infrastructure (Li, Niu, Papathanassiou and Wu 2014), allows high capital compa nies such as Apple to provide a better service to its consumers at a more efficient manner. The trend of using transit cards in China enables Apple to launch a new update (IOS 4.3) with the feature, which allows the users to make payments through their smartwatches. The increasing research and development (R&D) funding (i.e. China has a 5-Year Plan [2015-2020], where 2.2% of its GDP has be assigned for R&D) in China (ChinaPower n.d.) provides more space for innovations. |
Legal factors The Cybersecurity Law in China provides a secured informa tional platform for organizations to operate without the fear of cyberattacks and other threats (Orji 2012), by enforcing for eign firms to store data in China will limit their associated compliance risks. The new Foreign Investment Law will create a “stable, trans parent and predictable market environment for fair competi tion” (Zhang, Gao and Ben 2019). Intellectual property rights in China requires companies to purchase property rights (i.e. Patents) in relation to the use of software and hardware (Dimitrov 2009), which could add ad ditional costs for the company |
PESTEL Analysis |
Recommendation 1: to promote the Apple brand in China as one of the top 4 brand’s in their consideration set when pur chasing an electronic wearable through advertising on mediums such as television and social media strengths and points of differentiation from other mass produced Android devices. According to Pierini (2018), Apple current ly only has 9.7% of the Chinese mobile phone market share, where the majority (i.e. 80%) falls into the four biggest Chinese owned smartphone manufactures – Huawei, Oppo, Vivo, and Xiaomi. Although this strategy isn’t directly focused on increas ing sales of the Apple Watch, it is important for Apple to recognize that rational consumers with one of these 4 brands won’t buy the Apple Watch as it isn’t compatible with their Android operated device (unlike its competitors, i.e. Wear OS). Addi tionally points of differentiation for the Apple Watch is also reliant on it being connected to a compatible iPhone device. |
Recommendation 2: to expand the current market share through the increase of facilities (service span) or innovation omi) use the longevity of their batteries to promote their smartwatches. Therefore, it is recommended for Apple Watch to in vest in the area of using Solar Cell technology as a power source. Thus, users do not have to charge their smartwatches on a regular basis, which can be used effectively as a selling point in the electronic wearable industry. |
Recommendation 3: to concentrate on specific needs of different age categories Aging population of china keep growing and it is expected that in 30 years, 30% of population will be consisted with elder generation (Agencia EFE,2019).Therefore, it is important to focus on the elderly crowd without relying too much on younger generation. In order to attract elderly people, Apple can introduce a smart watch with specific features, i.e. the concentration of medication intake, doctor/therapists channelling, finding the locations of hospitals/aged care centres or set a reminder of doc tor appointments etc. |
Recommendation 4: to introduce an affordable version of smartwatch (similar quality) with basic functions Since Apple Watch is consider to be a comparative luxury item in China, consumers need to contemplate if they are willing to pay a premium price to obtain the watch. This has confined Apple to expand its market share and at the same time to compete with low priced smartwatch competitors. Therefore, in order to expand the market share, Apple can introduce a smartwatch with basic features at an affordable price. This will facilitate apple to exploit market share through attracting middle-class peo ple who love to possess branded items. Apple has already taken the approach of a ‘budget’ more cost effective iPhone with the XR model. Likewise with the Apple Watch, they could take a more similar approach where the display or other features that are not fundamental or considered as important to Chinese consumers can be loss in an effort to save costs of production, therefore a lower RRP. However, in this scenario Apple has to be mindful not to reduce its product quality parallel to its price as it will damage the reputation of the company. |
An advertisement on TV that promotes the advantages of using the iOS operating system when the Apple Watch is paired with
an iPhone, such as its capability in picking up tasks or viewing notes/schedules that were created on one device and able to be
viewed on the other device and vice versa.
Increase sales and usage of iPhone devices by launching comparative advertising on social media that highlights the iPhone’s
As Android is consumed by 80 % of the Chinese mobile phone market, an update in the “Watch iOS” can make it compatible
with the android operating system in order to attract Android users.
Apple has already allowed users to use their smartwatch to pay for transits in the main cities of China (Beijing and Shanghai).
It can be recommended to expand this facility to other cities and regions of China as public transport is a popular mode of
transportation and there is a high demand for the apple pay system in the cities mentioned above.
One of the major weaknesses of Apple watch is the comparative low battery life than its competitors; as competitors (i.e. Xia To take a further step in innovations, a hologram technology should be considered into the smart watches, so to provide users
with better visual experience (same as using a laptop/computer).
Although this option can be packaged as a premium Apple Watch, the introduction of the product may still be too futuristic
and would require a significant amount of investment on R&D.
Additionally, Apple Watch can expand the market to children, which allows them to use the smartwatch under the parents’
approval (i.e. limit the gaming time), or with build-in emergency contacts to allow better protection of children.
To increase the market share of Apple Watch in the electronic wearables industry in China to 8% by the end of September 2020
According to Passport GMID (n.d.), the current market share of Apple Watch in China is approximately 5.1% in 2018 for electronic wearables.
Reference:
Agencia EFE, ‘China’s elderly population to grow significantly in next 30 years’,EFE., 18 February, viewed 8 May 2019, <https://www.efe.com/efe/english/world/china-s-elderly-population-to-grow-significantly-in-next-30-years/50000262-3900621>.
Apple Inc. n.d., ‘Apple retail stores, China’, Apple Inc., viewed 13 May 2019, < https://www.apple.com/au/retail/storelist/>
Apple Inc. n.d., ‘Apple Watch Series 4’, Apple Inc., viewed 5 May 2019, < https://www.apple.com/cn/shop/buy-watch/apple-watch>
Apple Inc. n.d., ‘Supplier responsibility’, Apple Inc., viewed 5 May 2019, < https://www.apple.com/au/supplier-responsibility/>
Balding, C 2019,‘China Is Nationalizing Its Tech Sector’, Bloomberg Opinion, 12 April, viewed 8 May 2019, <https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2018-04-12/china-is-nationalizing-its-tech-sector>.
Carnoy, D 2018, ‘Samsung Galaxy Watch hand on: 4 ways its better than Apple Watch (so far)’, Cnet., viewed 2 May 2019, <https://www.cnet.com/reviews/samsung-galaxy-watch-preview/ >
Chen, C 2019, ‘This $80 smartwatch has a longer battery life than the Apple Watch or Fitbit and many of the same features — here’s what it’s like’, Business Insider., viewed 13 May 2019, <https://www.businessinsider.com/amazfit-bip-review-affordablesmartwatch-2018-8/?r=AU&IR=T >
ChinaPower, n.d., ‘Is China a global leader in research and development’, viewed 13 May 2019, <https://chinapower.csis.org/china-research-and-development-rnd/?fbclid=IwAR3KvsviWJq-hX7J2nnvNkvZP8vXu1dDkk1oU1vksdi8zsKR4zZF8wBXoLg>
Dimitrov, M., 2009. Piracy and the state: the politics of intellectual property rights in china. 2nd ed. London: Cambridge University press.
Draper, S 2019, ‘Children are Becoming Major Driving Force behind the Wearable Market Growth in China’, Wearable Technologies, 2 January, viewed 4 May 2019, < https://www.wearable-technologies.com/2019/01/children-are-becoming-major-driving-forcebehind-the-wearable-market-growth-in-china/>.
Duan, H. et al., 2008. Hazardous waste generation and management in china: A review. Journal of hazardous materials, 158 (2-3), 221-227
Jary, S 2019, ‘Fitbit vs Apple Watch’, Tech Advisor, 21 March, viewed 1 May 2019, < https://www.techadvisor.co.uk/feature/wearable-tech/fitbit-vs-apple-watch-2018-3612954/>.
Jiang, Y., 2009. China’s water scarcity. Journal of environmental management, 11, 3185-3196
Karam, S 2018, ‘ What are Xiaomi’s business strategies?’,Quora., viewed 13 May 2019, <https://www.quora.com/What-are-Xiaomis-business-strategies >
Lunicheva, A 2014, ‘Cultural factors in doing business in China’ , More than shipping, 16 May, Viewed 8 May 2019, <https://www.morethanshipping.com/cultural-factors-in-doing-business-in-china/>.
Orji, U., 2012. Cybersecurity Law & Regulation. 2nd ed. Netherlands: Wolf legal publishers.
Pierini, D 2018. ‘‘Research’ labels iPhone users in China as the ‘invisible poor’, Cult of Mac, viewed 17 May 2019, <https://www.cultofmac.com/592112/iphones-in-china/>
Sacconaghi, J, Garfunkel, EC & Colledge, JA 2005, ‘The Dell Migration and Threat of New Entrants’, White Book – Lexmark: Amid the Controversy, an Attractive Business Model & Valuation, pp. 47–53.
Salinas,S 2018, ‘Apple says Trump’s china tariffs are going to hurt the company’, CNBC, 09 September, viewed 7 May 2019,<https://www.cnbc.com/2018/09/07/proposed-tariff-list-covers-wide-range-of-apple-products-report.html>.
Samsung. n.d., ‘Samsung Galaxy Watch’, Samsung., viewed 13 May 2019,<https://www.corning.com/gorillaglass/worldwide/en/products-with-gorilla-glass/wearables/samsung/samsung-galaxy-watch.html >
Santander, 2019, ‘ China: Economic and political outline’, Santander—TradePortal, May, Viewed 8 May 2019, <https://en.portal.santandertrade.com/analyse-markets/china/economic-political-outline>.
The World Bank, 2017, ‘ Population ages 65 and above’, The World Bank—Data, 2017, Viewed 8 May 2019, <https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.POP.65UP.TO.ZS?end=2017&locations=CN&start=1960&view=chart>.
Tung, R., 2016. Opportunities and Challenges Ahead of China’s “New Normal”. Long Range Planning, vol. 49 no.5, 632-640
Wolff, FC 2016, ‘Bargaining powers of buyers and sellers on the online diamond market: a double perspective non-parametric analysis’, Annals of Operations Research, vol. 244, no. 2, pp. 697–718.